ASB Consulting & Tax

Tax

The biggest mistakes when lodging your own tax return

18 June 2026

Person reviewing expenses and calculations with a calculator and notebook while preparing a tax return at a desk

Every tax season, many people choose to lodge their own tax return. For some, it feels like the quickest option. The information is pre-filled, the questions seem straightforward, and the process can be completed in a relatively short amount of time.

What often surprises people is that the mistakes made in a tax return are not usually caused by entering the wrong number or clicking the wrong box.

More often, the issue is that important details are never considered in the first place.

At ASB Consulting & Tax, we regularly speak with people who believed their tax affairs were quite simple, only to discover there were deductions, income considerations or changes in circumstances that had not been properly reviewed.

The tax return trap: believing the ATO already knows everything

One of the biggest misconceptions we see every year is the belief that if information appears in the ATO system, then your tax return is essentially complete.

It’s easy to understand why people think this.

You log in, your salary is there, your bank interest is there, your private health insurance details are there, and it feels like most of the work has already been done.

The problem is that tax returns are not really about what the ATO already knows, they’re about what the ATO doesn’t know.

The system has no idea whether you spent three days a week working from your dining table. It doesn’t know that you paid for industry training to improve your skills. It doesn’t know about professional memberships, work-related purchases, or changes in your employment that may affect your position.

Working from home is a good example of an area where many people either underclaim, overclaim or simply misunderstand what applies to them. You can read more in our article, Claiming home office deductions in 2026.

Importantly, the ATO system doesn’t know what questions to ask.

As your accountant, we don’t simply review the information on the screen. We look at what happened in your life during the year.

  • Did your role change?
  • Did you start studying?
  • Did you take on additional responsibilities?
  • Did you incur costs because of the way you earn your income?

Those conversations often uncover things that would never appear in a pre-filled report.

The reality is that the ATO’s technology is excellent at collecting data. It is not designed to understand your circumstances.

That’s still where professional judgement, experience and asking the right questions make all the difference. And it’s why using an accountant will almost always get you a better outcome. 

Looking beyond the information already available

One of the limitations of preparing your own tax return is that the process generally focuses on information that is already known and readily available.

Most people enter the details they have in front of them and answer the questions presented by the system. What can be missed are the broader discussions about how your circumstances may have changed during the year and whether those changes have tax implications.

For example, a change in employment, undertaking further study, starting an investment portfolio or altering your work arrangements may all affect what needs to be considered in your return.

As your accountant, our role is not simply to enter information. It is to understand your circumstances, ask questions about what has happened during the year and identify areas that may require further attention.

Working with ASB Consulting & Tax means having experienced professionals review these details with you, helping ensure your tax return accurately reflects your situation, identifies opportunities you may not have considered and reduces the risk of important information being overlooked.

Assuming your situation is straightforward or the same as someone else’s

One of the comments we hear regularly is, “My situation is pretty straightforward.”

Sometimes that is true.

However, once we start talking about the year that has been, it is often not as straightforward as first thought.

A new role, a promotion, working from home, additional study, investment income, private health insurance, a side income stream or time away from work can all have an impact on a tax return.

None of these things are particularly unusual. They are simply part of life.

Another common assumption is that if someone else in the same profession claims certain deductions or has a particular tax outcome, the same rules will automatically apply to you.

In reality, two employees working in the same industry can have very different circumstances, expenses and entitlements. What applies to one person may not apply to another.

This is where conversations matter. A discussion about what happened during the year often uncovers details that would never appear on a standard checklist.

Many people are surprised to learn how often legitimate deductions are overlooked, particularly when relying on assumptions or generic deduction lists. Our article, You might be missing things in your tax return and not even realise it, explores some of the areas that are commonly missed. 

Why ASB takes the time to understand your situation 

At ASB, we do not see tax returns as forms to be completed. We see them as an opportunity to understand what has happened in your world over the past 12 months and make sure nothing important is missed.

That starts with a conversation.

We want to know about the new job, the promotion, the study you undertook, the investment you purchased, the side income you started or the changes that affected how and where you worked. These are often the details that never make it onto a standard checklist but can have a real impact on your tax position.

Our role is not simply to prepare and lodge a return. It is to ask the questions you may not think to ask yourself, identify opportunities that may otherwise be overlooked and help you understand how the tax rules apply to your specific circumstances.

Over the years, we have found that the best outcomes come from taking the time to understand the full picture.

That is why our clients value the process. They know they are not just getting a tax return lodged. They are getting advice, insight and a team that genuinely wants to help them achieve the best possible outcome.

Looking beyond the refund

One of the biggest misconceptions around tax time is that the size of your refund tells you whether you’ve done a good job with your tax return.

We get it. Everyone likes seeing money come back into their bank account.

But the reality is that a refund is only one part of the story.

What really matters is whether your tax return accurately reflects your circumstances and whether you’ve claimed everything you’re entitled to claim. Sometimes that results in a refund. Sometimes it simply means paying less tax and avoiding surprises later on.

The people who get the best outcomes are usually the ones who take the time to understand what happened during the year and how those events may affect their tax position.

That’s why our conversations with clients rarely start with “What refund am I getting?” They start with “What’s changed this year?”

Because more often than not, that’s where the opportunities are found.

Looking beyond the numbers

A tax return is more than a form to complete. It is an opportunity to review your circumstances, identify anything that may affect your tax outcome and ensure nothing important has been overlooked.

The right questions can often uncover deductions, obligations or opportunities that may not have been considered otherwise.

If you would like confidence that your tax return has been reviewed properly and reflects your individual circumstances, contact ASB Consulting & Tax. Our team can help you navigate tax time, answer your questions and ensure you achieve the best possible outcome based on your situation.


FAQs about lodging your own tax return

Is it better to use an accountant instead of lodging my own tax return?

Many people successfully lodge their own tax return each year. However, an accountant can help identify deductions, changes in circumstances and tax considerations that may not be obvious when completing a return online. Professional advice can also provide confidence that your return accurately reflects your situation.

Does the ATO pre-fill all the information needed for my tax return?

No. While the ATO receives information from employers, banks, private health insurers and other organisations, it does not automatically know about every deduction, work-related expense or change in your circumstances. A tax return should consider both the information reported to the ATO and your individual situation.

What are the most commonly overlooked items in a tax return?

Commonly overlooked areas can include work-related expenses, home office deductions, professional memberships, self-education expenses and changes in employment or investment activities. The deductions available will depend on your personal circumstances and the records you have maintained throughout the financial year.